To G. H. Darwin   3 May [1879]1

Down, | Beckenham, Kent. | Railway Station | Orpington. S.E.R.

May 3d

My dear G.

I have come across again Mr Keir’s statement in a letter to my Father, dated June 18th 1802, in which he twice refers to some malicious calumny about Dr. D. in the “Monthly magazine”.2 Will you have another look in the Cambridge Library. It may have been at close of 1801; but this is not likely.

Can the calumny be in some brief obituary notice at end of volume? It must have been some baddish calumny as it is said by Mr Keir, “that Dr. Fox & Mr Hadley have printed a declaration contradicting the falsehood”.3 Can there is two Monthly Magazines, slightly differing, such as the “Gentlemans Monthly Magazine” or “London Monthly Mag”, &c & that the first half of Title was dropped as my Father knew to what magazine Mr Keir referred. See what you can do to help me.—

Yours affect | C. Darwin

The year is established by the references to research for Erasmus Darwin, which was published in 1879.
‘Biographical memoir of the late Dr. Darwin’ had been published anonymously in the Monthly Magazine, or, British Register, 1 June 1802 (Anon. 1802). James Keir had been a close friend of Erasmus Darwin; his letter to CD’s father, Robert Waring Darwin (1766–1848), is in DAR 227.6: 81.
The article in the Monthly Magazine claimed that Erasmus Darwin’s death had been hastened by ‘a violent fit of passion’ directed towards a servant (Anon. 1802, p. 458). In the draft, but not the published version, of Erasmus Darwin, CD stated that this had been denied by Erasmus’s medical attendants, Francis Fox and Henry Hadley (King-Hele ed. 2003, pp. 69 and 127). The denial by Fox and Hadley was published in the Derby Mercury, 10 June 1802, p. 4.

Manuscript Alterations and Comments

1.4 this is] ‘is’ interl
2.1 Can] after del ‘Coul’
2.1 at end of volume] interl
2.5 &c] interl

Please cite as “DCP-LETT-12028,” in Ɛpsilon: The Charles Darwin Collection accessed on 5 June 2025, https://epsilon.ac.uk/view/dcp-data/letters/DCP-LETT-12028