Samuel Hunter Christie to Faraday   14 April 1833

Woolwich Common | 14th April 1833

My dear Sir,

I thank you for your early communication of the announcement of Keil's discoveries 1, and in return send you a Letter to the editor of the True Sun. I will thank you to read it over, and if you think any part will be better omitted, to strike it out after which I must trouble you to get it conveyed to the office of the True Sun. I have taken the whole upon my own shoulders for I considered that having introduced the learned & modest Professor at the meeting2, a simple denial of my sanction of his discoveries was not sufficient. I agree with you that the True Sun is not the paper best calculated for the contradiction of Keil's statement to produce effect, but still it ought to be contradicted in the paper in which it appears3. I have however no objection to my statement or any part of it being published in any other paper. I think it would be proper that a joint contradiction of the last paragraph should be drawn up, and sent to the Times and another morning paper. If you will have this done I shall be quite ready to sign it. Mr Barlow, to whom I have shewn the modest puff, would I think likewise do so. I say that we shall have the odium of attempting to stifle discovery Keil & Co the credit of making it; and, what is more, I suspect after all, they will have the profit, not that their "acknowledged scientific attainments and veracity" merit, but which "interested empires" generally reap. Perhaps you will be able to call on Tuesday evening. I trust you have before this quite got rid of cold &c. With best compts to Mrs Faraday, I am

Ever yours truly | S.H. Christie

Michael Faraday Esq

"Professor Keil's Discoveries in Magnetism", True Sun, 11 April 1833, [p.2, col. d], reported a meeting of the Royal Society in which Keil described his work on magnetism and its uses for curing diseases. The final paragraph of the report stated that Keil's work had received the sanction of Faraday, Christie and Barlow amongst others. This matter was also reported in a letter to the Lit.Gaz., 13 April 1833, p. 234.
Professor Keel was introduced by Christie a meeting of the Royal Society on 14 March 1833, RS MS JB 46: 745. There is no indication here that Keil spoke.
Christie's letter appeared in the True Sun, 17 April 1833, [p.4, col. e].

Please cite as “Faraday0655,” in Ɛpsilon: The Michael Faraday Collection accessed on 3 May 2024, https://epsilon.ac.uk/view/faraday/letters/Faraday0655