To John Frederick William Herschel   17th Sep. 1864.

Royal Institution of Great Britain | 17th Sep. 1864.

Dear Sir John,

Your excellent letter1 in the Athenaeum, which I trust will have the effect of stifling that contemptible ‘Declaration’2 reminds me that I received in a remote corner of the Italian Alps a most interesting letter3 from your pen; that I on my arrival in Bormio4 posted a note to you in reply to that letter; that I enclosed the note in a letter to my friend Mrs Frederick Pollock,5 but that I now find that the letter never reached Mrs Pollock,6 and that consequently the enclosure never reached you.

I told you in that note that I purposed reprinting that fine passage from the Outlines of 18337 regarding the operations of the sun, in the 2nd edition of my book8 now in preparation, I have already copied it, and it will duly reach the printer’s hands.

I also referred to the extremely philosophical views of muscular contraction contained in your letter,9 and suggested the desirability of publishing that portion of the letter which referred to this subject.

If delay therefore has occurred in replying to a letter which I valued very much it has been caused by the ineffable stupidity and carelessness of the post office people in the Italian valleys of the Alps.

Yours most truly | John Tyndall.

RS HS 394a

RI MS JT/1/TYP/2/528

Your excellent letter: Herschel wrote to the Athenaeum to protest against being pressed to sign a ‘religious manifesto’, on the grounds that it was both an infringement of his freedom of religious opinion, and an action likely to sow discord in the Christian world. He also insisted that his refusal to sign should not be seen as a profession of atheism or infidelity (see ‘Science and Scripture’, Athenaeum, 17 September 1864, p. 375).

‘Declaration’: see letter 2104, n. 4.

most interesting letter: letter 2111.

Bormio: see letter 2139, n. 4.

Mrs Frederick Pollock: Juliet Pollock.

I now find that the letter never reached Mrs Pollock: see letter 2135.

Outlines of 1833: see letter 2111, n. 8.

the 2nd edition of my book: see letter 2139, n. 3.

your letter: letter 2111.

Please cite as “Tyndall2140,” in Ɛpsilon: The John Tyndall Collection accessed on 5 June 2025, https://epsilon.ac.uk/view/tyndall/letters/Tyndall2140