WCP2288

Letter (WCP2288.2178)

[1]

Chislehurst.

Augt 12. 1872

Dear Mr. Wallace,

I am much obliged for yr note1 & quite agree with you that my paper2 would have been more complete if I had added tables showing the presence & absence of Moluccan genera. Perhaps I may find an opportunity of doing so yet. With regard to living Javan and Bornean genera present & absent, my difficulty would be that no complete list of species from either island has been [illeg.] and although I have a fair knowledge of what genera [2] do inhabit those islands, yet it is far from perfect. In fact we want Catalogues for all the great Ind. Malay islands. & I have begun to attack Borneo & am on a list of Philippine birds.

= I have just received from Marudi in Borneo examples of Argus grayi, Elliot3 – it is a good species, quite distinct from the common Argus & this settles the doubt about its habitat.

= I have also received a fine [3] series of Barita gymnocephala Tem., from Marudi — If not trespassing on yr time would you kindly tell me what you know of its habits and what you think of its affinities? Whatever you write I will introduce in my remarks on the species. I have written out for specimens in spirits.

= The Bornean small Spilornis is a good and distinct species.

= I enjoyed yr castigation4 of Dr Bree5 "Fools [4] rush in. etc " as much in Science as in every other pursuit.

Believe me | Yrs. very tru[l]y | Walden6 [signature]

There is a bad misprint in my Celebean paper which you may perhaps think is worth while to correct on the margin. At page 115, line 11 please to read

"a diminutive form of C. monticolus, Frank"

W.

Walden, Arthur, Viscount. 1872. A List of the Birds known to inhabit the Island of Celebes. Transactions of the Zoological Society of London, 8: 23-108. Read to the Royal Society on 2 May 1871.
Elliot, Daniel Giraud (1835-1915). American zoologist.
Wallace, Alfred R.1872. The Last Attack on Darwinism. Nature, 6 (143), 237-239; a review of Bree, Charles R. 1872. An Exposition of Fallacies in the Hypothesis of Mr. Darwin. London: Longmans, Green and Co.
Bree, Charles Robert (1811-1886). British physician and zoologist.
Hay, Arthur (1824-1878). British army officer and ornithologist. Ninth marquess of Tweeddale, Scotland. Known before 1862 as Lord Arthur Hay and between 1862 and 1876 as Viscount Walden.

Please cite as “WCP2288,” in Beccaloni, G. W. (ed.), Ɛpsilon: The Alfred Russel Wallace Collection accessed on 5 June 2025, https://epsilon.ac.uk/view/wallace/letters/WCP2288