WCP3428

Letter (WCP3428.2915)

[1]

Bishop Auckland

May 4 / 74

Dear Sir

As an investigator & adherent of spiritualism I have read parts of yr article in the 'Fortnightly'1 with pleasure.

When the first evidence of the subject came before me some eight years ago I got interested & have pursued the matter since with unceasing pleasure ——

During 1868 I chanced to meet with a tract on the subject in which a statement was made to the effect that John Stuart Mill,2 Ruskin,3 Tennyson,4 Longfellow5 &c have become believers.

I was incredulous at any [2] note of Mills' conversion & posted the tract to him saying if he thought well I wd. be glad to hear his attestation or otherwise.

The enclosed letter6 came in reply and as it is interesting as showing how unphilosophical a life philosophical mind can be, when scarce any amount of evidence wd. reach its depths, I submit a copy of it to you for use as a note or as you thought fit in your part 2nd of the article for next months 'Fortnightly'. In case you think proper to use it, on receipt of [3] your reply I will send you the original for your satisfaction.

Yours truly | N. Kilburn7 [signature]

To

Alfred Wallace Esq.

Wallace, A. R. 1874. A defence of modern spiritualism. Fortnightly Review (n.s.) 15 (89): 630-657.
Mill, John Stuart (1806-1873). British philosopher, political economist and civil servant.
Ruskin, John (1819-1900). British writer, art critic and social thinker.
Tennyson, Alfred (1809-1892). British Poet.
Longfellow, Henry Wadsworth (1807-1882). American poet.
Kilburn, Nicholas (1843-1923). British manufacturer and musician.

Enclosure (WCP3428.5509)

[1]

(Copy)

Blackheath Park

Kent

March 18 1868

Dear Sir

I have to thank you for your inclosure & inquiry.

It is the first time I ever heard that I was a believer in spiritualism, and I am not sorry to be able to suppose that some of the other names I have seen mentioned as believers in it are no more so than myself.

For my own part, I not only have never seen any evidence that I think of the slightest weight in favour of spiritualism [2] but I should also find it very difficult to believe any of it on any evidence whatever, and I am in the habit of expressing my opinion to that effect very freely whenever the subject is mentioned in my presence.

You are at liberty to make any use you please of this letter.

I am sir | yours very truly | J. S. Mill [signature]

to N Kilburn1 Esqre

Kilburn, Nicholas (1843-1923). British manufacturer and musician.

Please cite as “WCP3428,” in Beccaloni, G. W. (ed.), Ɛpsilon: The Alfred Russel Wallace Collection accessed on 5 June 2025, https://epsilon.ac.uk/view/wallace/letters/WCP3428