WCP4072

Letter (WCP4072.4016)

[1]

Broadstone, Wimborne

May 3rd. 1907

Revd. Archdeacon Colley1

Dear Sir

The picture you send me is not like what I saw. From the first appearance of the filmy white patch on Monck's2 coat the white patch preserved its tolerably regular outline, being only "cloudy" in colour & apparently softness, never with any such irregularity (suggesting actual vapour) as in your drawing. By the time the figure was separated [2] from Monck & drew away from him, it had formed into definite white drapery covering it from head to foot, with no vapouriness or cloudiness (such as your picture shows). It simply grew into drapery over a female form — not one particle escaping into irregularly cloudy matter.

Of course this was one case only & in full daylight. [3] These things never happen exactly alike, & you know best whether the picture represents what you saw.

Allow me to congratulate you on the verdict in your favour though you ought to have had more damages on the libel — & would have had if the Judge had not been against you.

Yours very truly | Alfred R. Wallace [signature]

The picture received & returned today A.R.W

Colley, Thomas (1839-1912). Archdeacon and spiritualist. Rector of Stockton from 1901-1912. In 1876, he had participated in the exposure of the fraudulent medium, William Eglington. However, later he would defend the materialisation phenomena of F. W. Monck.
Monck, Francis Ward (1842-). British clergyman and Spiritualist medium.

Envelope (WCP4072.4017)

Envelope addressed to "Revd. Archdeacon Colley, Stockton Rectory, Warwickshire", with stamp, postmarked "BROADSTONE | A | MY 3 | 07". Pencil note on front of envelope "With copy to 55 saying how our accounts agree & his definition of a medium"; postmark on back. [Envelope (WCP4072.4017)]

Please cite as “WCP4072,” in Beccaloni, G. W. (ed.), Ɛpsilon: The Alfred Russel Wallace Collection accessed on 5 June 2025, https://epsilon.ac.uk/view/wallace/letters/WCP4072