WCP4459

Letter (WCP4459.4767)

[1]

Returned Letter1

Old Orchard,

Broadstone,

Dorset.

Jany.. 18th. 1913

Ben. R. Miller Esq.

Dear Sir

Thanks for your kind congratulations, & for the small pamphlet you have sent me. I have read it with much interest, as the writer was evidently a man of thought and talent. The first lecture certainly gives an approach to Darwin’s theory, perhaps neater[?] than any other, as he almost implies the "Survival of the fittest" as the cause of progressive modification. But his language is imaginative & obscure. He uses "Education" apparently in [2] the sense of what we should term "effect of the environment".

The second lecture is even a more exact anticipation of the modern views as to microbes, including their transmissions by fleas & other insects, and the probability that the blood of healthy persons contains a sufficiency of destroyers of the pathogenic germs, such as the white blood corpuscles — to preserve us in health.

But he is so anti-clerical & anti-Biblical that it is no wonder he could not get a hearing in Boston [3] in 1847.

Yours very truly| Alfred R. Wallace [signature]

Published letter (WCP4459.6457)

[1] [p. 98]

Old Orchard

Broadstone,

Dorset

January 18, 1913

Dear Sir,—Thanks for your kind congratulations, and for the small pamphlet1 you have sent me. I have read it with much interest, as the writer was evidently a man of thought and talent. The first lecture certainly gives [2] [p. 99] an approach to Darwin's theory, perhaps nearer than any other, as he almost implies the "survival of the fittest" as the cause of progressive modification. But his language is imaginative and obscure. He uses "education" apparently in the sense of what we should term "effect of the environment."

The second lecture is even a more exact anticipation of the modern views as to microbes, including their transmission by flies and other insects and the probability that the blood of healthy persons contains a sufficiency of destroyers of the pathogenic germs—such as the white blood-corpuscles—to preserve us in health.

But he is so anti-clerical and anti-Biblical that it is no wonder he could not get a hearing in Boston in 1847.—Yours very truly,

Alfred R. Wallace

There is a superscript "2" here but no footnote is given.

Please cite as “WCP4459,” in Beccaloni, G. W. (ed.), Ɛpsilon: The Alfred Russel Wallace Collection accessed on 27 April 2024, https://epsilon.ac.uk/view/wallace/letters/WCP4459