WCP5728

[1] [p. 175]

Broadstone, Dorset.

July 24, 1907.

Dear Mr. Smedley,

—... I write chiefly to tell you that I have read Mr. Lowell's¹ last book, "Mars and its[2] [p. 176] Canals,"² and am now writing an article, or perhaps a small book, about it. I am sure his theories are all wrong, and I am showing why, so that anyone can see his fallacies. His observations, drawings, photographs, etc., are all quite right, and I believe true to nature, but his interpretation of what he sees is wrong — often even to absurdity. He began by thinking the straight lines are works of art, and as he finds more and more of these straight lines, he thinks that proves more completely that they are works of art, and then he twists all other evidence to suit that. The book is not very well written, but no doubt the newspaper men think that as he is such a great astronomer he must know what it all means!

I am more than ever convinced that Mars is totally uninhabitable....—

Yours very truly, | Alfred R. Wallace.