WCP1895

Letter (WCP1895.1785)

[1]

4 Chester Place R. Park. N.W

Until April 1st

March 27th [1868]1

My dear Wallace

My son2 has failed in your problem & says that it is "exceedingly excessively difficult": he says you will find something about it in Thompson & Tait Nat[ural]. Philos[ophy] (Art. 649).3 He has, however sent the solution, if the plate rested on a square rim, but he supposes this will not answer your purpose; [2] nevertheless I have forwarded it by this same post.— It seems that the rim being round makes the problem much more difficult.—

I enclose my photograph, which I have received from Down.

I sent your answer to George on his objections to your [one illeg. word crossed out] argument on sterility but have not yet heard from him.— I dread beginning to think over this fearful [3] problem, which I believe beats the plate on the circular rim; but I will sometime. I foresee, however, that there are so many doubtful points, that we shall never agree.

As far as a glance serves it seems to me, perhaps falsely, that you sometimes argue that hybrids have [4] an advantage from greater vigour, & sometimes a disadvantage from not being so well fitted to their conditions.— Heaven protect my stomach whenever I attempt following your argument.—

Your’s most sincerely | C. Darwin [signature]

'1868' is added as a circled annotation in the upper left-hand corner of page 1. The year of 1868 has been established as correct by the Darwin Correspondence Project See DCP-LETT-6058.
Darwin, George Howard (1845-1912). 2nd son of Charles Robert Darwin; astronomer and mathematician.
Thomson, W. & Tait, P. G. 1867. Treatise on Natural Philosophy. Oxford: Clarendon Press, pp.496-497.

Published letter (WCP1895.5982)

[1] [p. 206]

4 Chester Place, Regent's Park, N.W. March 27, 1868.

My dear Wallace, — My son has failed in your problem, and says that it is "excessively difficult": he says you will find something about it in Thomson and Tait, "Natural Philosophy" (art. 649). He has, however, sent the solution, if the plate rested on a square rim, but he supposes this will not answer your purpose; nevertheless, I have forwarded it by this same post. It seems that the rim being round makes the problem much more difficult.

I enclose my photograph, which I have received from Down. I sent your answer to George on his objection to your argument on sterility, but have not yet heard from him. I dread beginning to think over this fearful problem, [2] which I believe beats the plate on the circular rim; but I will sometime. I foresee, however, that, there are so many doubtful points that we shall never agree. As far as a glance serves it seems to me, perhaps falsely, that you sometimes argue that hybrids have an advantage from greater vigour, and sometimes a disadvantage from not being so well fitted to their conditions. Heaven protect my stomach whenever I attempt following your argument! — Yours most sincerely, C. DARWIN.

Please cite as “WCP1895,” in Beccaloni, G. W. (ed.), Ɛpsilon: The Alfred Russel Wallace Collection accessed on 24 April 2024, https://epsilon.ac.uk/view/wallace/letters/WCP1895