WCP1924

Letter (WCP1924.4084)

[1]1

9, St Mark’s Crescent N.W.

Oct[obe]r. 20th. 1869.

Dear Darwin

I do not know your son’s (Mr G[eorge]. Darwin’s)2 address at Cambridge. Will you be so good as to forward him the enclosed note begging for a little information.3

I was delighted to see the notice in the "Academy"4 that you are really going to bring out your book on Man.5I anticipate for it an enormous sale, and shall read it with intense interest, although I expect to find in it more to differ from than in any of your other books.

Some reasonable and reasoning opponents are now taking the field. I have been writing a little notice6 of Murphy’s7 book "Habit & Intelligence"8, — which with much that is strange & unintelligible contains some very acute criticisms and the statement [2] of a few real difficulties.

Another article just sent me from "The Month" — contains some good criticism[.]9 How incipient organs can be useful is a real difficulty, so is the independent origin of similar complex organs; — but most of his other points though well put are not very formidable.

I am trying to begin a little book on the "Distribution of Animals", but I fear I shall not make much of it from my idleness in collecting facts. I shall make it a popular sketch first, and if it succeeds gather materials for enlarging it at a future time.

If any suggestion occurs to you as to the kind of maps that would be [3] best, or on any other essential point, I sh[oul]d. be glad of a hint.

I hope your residence in Wales did you good. I had no idea you were so near Dolgelly [Dolgellau] till I met you over there one evening when I was going to leave the next morning. It is a glorious country but the time I like is May and June — the foliage is so glorious.

Sincerely hoping you are pretty well & with kind regards to Mrs Darwin10 & the rest of your family

Believe me| Yours very faithfully| Alfred R. Wallace [signature]

C. Darwin Esq.

Darwin adds a scored red crayon line down the left-hand margin of page 1 from the text "I have" to "the statement."
Darwin, George Howard (1845-1912). Astronomer and mathematician and 2nd son of Charles Robert Darwin.
The enclosure to George Howard Darwin has not been found. See WCP1926.1816 for George's reply to ARW's enclosure.
Anon. 1869. Scientific Notes. Academy 1: 15-16.
Darwin, C. 1871. The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex. 1st Ed. 2 vols. London, UK: John Murray.
Wallace, A. R. 1869. The Origin of Species Controversy I. Nature 1: 105-107 (25 Nov. 1869) / II. Nature 1: 132-133 (2 Dec. 1869).
Murphy, Joseph John (1827-1894). Irish author on philosophy, logic, psychology and religion.
Murphy, J. J. 1869. Habit and Intelligence in Their Connexion with the Laws of Matter and Force: a Series of Scientific Essays. 2 vols. London: Macmillan and Co.
Mivart, St. George. 1869. Difficulties of the Theory of Natural Selection. The Month. 11: 35-53, 134-153, 274-289.
Darwin, Emma (née Wedgwood) (1808-1896). Wife and first cousin of Charles Robert Darwin.

Transcription (WCP1924.1814)

[1]

To C.Darwin.) 9, St.Mark's Crescent N.W. Oct. 20th. 1869

Dear Darwin I do not know your son's (Mr G.Darwin's) address at Cambridge. Will you be so good as to forward him the enclosed note begging for a little information.

I was delighted to see the notice in the "Academy" that you are really going to bring out your book on Man. I anticipate for it an enormous sale, and shall read it with intense interest, although I expect to find in it more to differ from than in any of your other books. Some reasonable and reasoning opponents are now taking the field. I have been writing a little notice of Murphy's "Habit & Intelligence",— which with much that is strange & unintelligible contains some very acute criticisms and the statement of a few real difficulties. Another article just sent me from "the Month" — contains some good criticism. How incipient organs can be useful is a real difficulty, so is the independent origin of similar complex organs,— but most of his other points though well put are not very formidable. I am trying to begin a little book on the "Distribution of Animals", but I fear I shall not make much of it from my idleness in collecting facts. I shall make it a popular sketch first, and if it succeeds gather materials for enlarging it at a future time. If any suggestion occurs to you as to the kind of maps that would be best, or on any other essential point, I sh'd be glad of a hint. I hope your residence in Wales did you good. I had no idea you were so near Dolgally till I met your son there one evening when I was going to leave the next morning. It is a glorious country but the time I like is May and June — the foliage is so glorious. Sincerely hoping you are pretty well & with kind regards to Mrs Darwin & the rest of your family Believe me

Yours very faithfully Alfred R. Wallace.

Transcription (WCP1924.4500)

[1]

To C.Darwin.) 9,St.Mark’s Crescent N.W. Oct. 20th. 1869

Dear Darwin

I do not know your son’s (Mr. G.Darwin’s1) address at Cambridge. Will you be so good as to forward him the enclosed note begging for a little information.

I was delighted to see the notice in the "Academy" that you are really going to bring out your book on Man. I anticipate for it an enormous sale, and shall read it with intense interest, although I expect to find in it more to differ from than in any of your other books.

Some reasonable and reasoning opponents are now taking the field. I have been writing a little notice of Murphy’s "Habit & Intelligence"2,- which with much that is strange and unintelligible contains some very acute criticisms and the statement of a few real difficulties

Another article just sent me from "the Month"- contains some good criticism. How incipient organs can be useful is a real difficulty, so is the independent origin of similar complex organs,— but most of his other points though well put are not very formidable.

I am trying to begin a little book on the "Distribution of Animals", but I fear I shall not make much of it from my idle-ness in collecting facts. I shall make it a popular sketch first, a and if it succeeds gather materials for enlarging it at a future time.

If any suggestion occurs to you as to the kind of maps that would be best, or on any other essential point, I sh[oul]d be glad of a hint.

I hope your residence in Wales did you good. I had no idea you were so near Dolgally3 till I met your son there one evening when I was going to leave the next morning. It is a glorious country but the time I like is May and June — the foliage is so glorious.

Sincerely hoping you are pretty well & with kind regards to Mrs Darwin & the rest of your family.

Believe me | Yours very faithfully | Alfred R.Wallace. [signature]

George Howard Darwin (1845 — 1912)
John Joseph Murphy, "Habit and Intelligence, in their connexion with the laws of Matter and Force" 1869.
Modern name Dolgellau, a town in north-west Wales

Published letter (WCP1924.6011)

[1] [p. 246]

9 St. Mark's Crescent, N.W. October 20, 1869.

Dear Darwin, — I do not know your son's (Mr. George Darwin's) address at Cambridge. Will you be so good as to forward him the enclosed note begging for a little information?

I was delighted to see the notice in the Academy that you are really going to bring out your book on Man. I anticipate for it an enormous sale, and shall read it with intense interest, although I expect to find in it more to differ from than in any of your other books. Some reasonable and reasoning opponents are now taking the field. I have been writing a little notice of Murphy's "Habit and Intelligence," which, with much that is strange and unintelligible, contains some very acute criticisms and the statement of a few real difficulties. Another article just sent me from the Month contains some good criticism. How incipient organs can be useful is a real difficulty, so is the independent origin of similar complex organs; but most of his other points, though well put, are not very formidable. I am trying to begin a little book on the Distribution of Animals, but I fear I shall not make much of it from my idleness in collecting facts. [2]

I shall make it a popular sketch first, and, if it, succeeds, gather materials for enlarging it at a future time. It any suggestion occurs to you as to the kind of maps that would be best, or on any other essential point, I should be glad of a hint. I hope your residence in Wales did you good. I had no idea you were so near Dolgelly till I met your son there one evening when I was going to leave the next morning. It is a glorious country, but the time I like is May and June — the foliage is so glorious.

Sincerely hoping you are pretty well, and with kind regards to Mrs. Darwin and the rest of your family, believe me yours very faithfully, ALFRED R. WALLACE.

Please cite as “WCP1924,” in Beccaloni, G. W. (ed.), Ɛpsilon: The Alfred Russel Wallace Collection accessed on 25 April 2024, https://epsilon.ac.uk/view/wallace/letters/WCP1924