WCP5337

[1]

Aug 30 [18]68

Dear old Darwin

A thousand thanks for your letter¹. A regular sun-beam it was — What a pother these papers kick up about my mild theology! An Aberdeen one calls me an Atheist & all that is bad: to me, who do not intend to answer their abuse, misquotations, garbled extracts, & blunders, it is all really very good fun. There were gentle disapproving allusions at Kew Church today I am told! [2] I am beginning to feel quite a great man!

Tyndall² most assuredly did couple our names most prominently, unequivocally, & unmistakeably as the two modestest men in Science!!!

The last day was by far the hardest work, what with Committees & Councils & the Mayor’s³ Dejeuner [French: lunch] — & Huxleys⁴ splendid lecture⁵ to the Working men — on all which occasions I had to speak. — I never had such a day’s work, & had rest ^no rest whatever, from 10 am till [3] 10 ½ PM. I could not sleep at night, & had to give up the excursions next day. My darling wife⁶ did enjoy it all through most thoroughly, & proved herself "as strong as a woman" I am sure that without her the whole thing would have been to me simply intolerable; as it was, it was delightful to see her always in public & looking so pretty ^{(at a distance at least)} & pleased.

The sections were splendidly full all through. Poor Huxley made a sad mess of it by twice offending the clergy,⁷[—] The Clergy throughout behaved splendidly like men & gentlemen. The Cathedral service was glorious, the anthem was chosen for me "What though I know each Herb & Flower" & brought tears into my eyes, & D^r Magees⁸ discourse⁹ was the grandest ever heard by Tyndall[,] Berkeley¹⁰, Spottiswoode¹¹, Hirst¹², or myself. [—] totally without cause or warrant, — once at the Prehisto<ry> [4] Congress¹³, when he likened them to Bulls of Basan¹⁴ [sic] — & again at the Red Lion Club¹⁵, when they got up & left the room! I was not there having providentially been prevented attending. On this last occasion he had no intention of hit ^hitting the Clergy, but ^{Carl Vogt16}[.] had some No one understood this at the time, & whether or no the application was obvious, & the blunder atrocious. Several got drunk as usual at the Red Lions — I do wish I could persuade Lubbock¹⁷ to drop that very silly Club. he is now the head & front of it; & it really is a scandal to Science, & however ^{it might have once been} good under E. Forbes¹⁸ 25 years ago [5] is now completely out of place, out of date, & out of keeping with the age & standing of the Members[.] Stokes¹⁹ has accepted the Presidency for next year, & if he is as dull & wanting in tact as at Norwich, the Exeter meeting will not be brilliant.

My time was an anxious one as Willy²⁰ who was staying with an old messmate of mine at Oxford burst a blood vessel in the Lungs on the very day of meeting, & we are a good deal anxious about him — We had constant letters & Telegrams, & my wife was ready to start at a minutes warning, but his good kind hosts would not allow it — & it [6] would have made an awful row at Norwich. I went from Norwich to Oxford on Friday & brought him home on Saturday. He has had several slight returns, but is otherwise well, has no cough or bad symptom. The Oxford Doctor, an excellent man, declares that it is from the Lungs, ^{& dreads tubercle,} but can detect no lesion. We are keeping him very quiet, & he is not to go back to school this quarter.

I have between £8 & 9. to hand over to Mrs Cameron²¹ for sale of photographs, cheifly [sic] yours, of which 8 or 10 went off; but it is far too big for travellers [7] to carry away. I wrote twice to her from Norwich.

Asa Gray²² sails on 2^d Sept from New York.

I forgot to tell you that I read all over about you to Thomson²³ who thought I had "drawn it very mild" — Bentham²⁴ & Oliver²⁵ do not think that I said a word too much.

The astronomers do not quite like my allusions to them. I had a long talk with Adams,²⁶ who is a most charming fellow, he will not agree with me, but won't give me any definite answer. He does not allow that astronomy is in fault in the matter of the moon's ^suns [8] distance, no more it is in one sense, but astronomers are, & the science ^{of astronomy} is simply the exponent of astronomers knowledge —

Lady Lyell²⁷ was much pleased at my notice of Sir Cha[rle]s'²⁸ book²⁹ & thanked me very heartily. Sir C[harles]. said nothing — Wallace³⁰ was charmed. & so was Flower.³¹

I am longing to run to Down & tell you all about it — but I must go to Scotland next week (7^th or 8^th) to settle about ^{the late} D^r Arnott’s³² Library & Herb[ariu]^m. & then for a few days visit to a friend³³ near Dunfermline.

As soon as I can after my return I will run down ^{to you} (& bring my wife, if convenient to Mrs Darwin³⁴, & Willy keeps well, so that she may go without anxiety.) —

Love to all | Ever y[ou]r[s] affec[tionately] | J D Hooker [signature]

I³⁵ gave your Reindeer Query to Nilsson³⁶ & saw a great deal of Victor Carus³⁷.

P.S. I have just seen Owen’s³⁸ rigmarole in the Athenaeum³⁹, is it worth answering?